Le Boudoir de Marie-Antoinette

Prenons une tasse de thé dans les jardins du Petit Trianon
AccueilAccueil  PortailPortail  FAQFAQ  RechercherRechercher  S'enregistrerS'enregistrer  Connexion  

Partagez | 

 Sofia Coppola's Marie Antoinette is a Tragic Feminist Hero

Aller en bas 


Nombre de messages : 40175
Date d'inscription : 23/05/2007

MessageSujet: Sofia Coppola's Marie Antoinette is a Tragic Feminist Hero   Sam 3 Nov - 9:45

Sofia Coppola's Marie Antoinette is a Tragic Feminist Hero

Vous êtes d'accord avec ça ? Wink

Although she was born 263 years ago this week, Marie Antoinette still remains a controversial figure. So much so, that when Sofia Coppola premiered her eponymous film about the executed queen of France at the 2006 Cannes film festival, it was booed. But since then, the retelling has become an unlikely story of quiet feminine strength.

Before shooting Marie Antoinette piecemeal at Versailles Palace during the one day a week it wasn’t open to visitors, Coppola was already two films and an Academy Award deep (best original screenplay for
Lost in Translation) into her career. The second-generation auteur had established a lens flare-laced shorthand for portraying the loneliness of women, full of potential but trapped in a system designed to deny them a voice. It was a thematic disposition that translated well into the new setting.

Based on Lady Antonia Fraser's biography (itself described as a highly revisionist work), Coppola’s film subverted the story of the girl sold as a child bride to strengthen international relations with even further liberal use of anachronisms. That stylistic choice meant when the 14-year-old Austrian princess entered the royal French court, she was entering a world where she could wear Manolo Blahniks and Converse and snack on Ladurée macaroons. All these exploits were soundtracked by a genre-gobbling score that included original piano work by Dustin O'Halloran, punk rock classics from Siouxsie and the Banshees and Bow Wow Wow, and modern slacker pop from The Strokes and The Radio Dept.

This mix of the old and new wasn’t entirely unfamiliar to audiences. After all, Baz Luhrmann had employed a similar technique 10 years earlier in his 1996 retelling of Romeo + Juliet. But if Coppola’s frilly, pink-drenched vision of pre-war France was meant to convey a link to the present, the content, which resonates with anyone in this #MeToo, glass-cracked-but-not-shattered era, spoke for itself. Marie Antoinette is the story of both a woman denied a voice—as evidenced by the fact Antoinette (played with a cheerful determination by Kirsten Dunst) doesn’t have a substantial line until nearly 40 minutes into the film—and those okay with maintaining the status quo. (See: Louis XVI, played with perfect distraction by Jason Schwartzman, who rather played with keys than be bothered to engage with his wife.)

Perhaps that’s why her tiny moments of rebellion hit with such resonance, even if the film’s narrative liberties are rarely backed up by history. From clapping after a court opera performance and getting on stage herself to actively opting to take an active role in raising her children (at a fake chateau in Versailles park gardens, no less) and then taking a lover when her husband refuses to engage, Coppola’s Antoinette is a woman struggling to make the system work in her favor. And speaking out when it didn’t.

“This is ridiculous,” Antoinette tells her attendees during a protracted morning dressing ceremony that requires the highest-ranking royal in the room to help her dress. “This, madam, is Versailles,” she’s informed.

But perhaps
Marie Antoinette’s greatest achievement is refusing to paint its protagonist as someone who needs be perfect in order for us to sympathize with her. Antoinette’s famous brush-off declaration “Let them eat cake” is presented in the film as some kind of fake news aside, which she vehemently denies uttering. (In fairness, history is oblique about this claim.) She is indulgent to a fault, dancing until dawn, sneaking off to balls, and when faced with the idea of brokering peace between nations, she opts to discuss dress fabrics, or add additional height to her already architecturally impressive wigs. Her coronation at the age of 19 concedes with the film’s most lavish sequence, as (like one assumes any teenagers would be wont to do) she and Louis stage a string of parties featuring fireworks, gambling, masquerades, and two pirate ships dueling in the palace garden lakes.

But this is the same woman who, like Coppola’s characters in the Virgin Suicides, wasn’t given any options other than slow-motion destruction. Perhaps the biggest complaint leveled at the film is that it’s heavy on atmosphere (its lavish pastry-like costumes won designer Milena Canonero an Oscar), and light on plot. But then again, wasn’t Antoinette’s life? Even when an angry mob forces her family to flee Versailles (they would be become the figureheads for France’s debut and social problems and were eventually executed in 1793), Coppola shows Antoinette as woman who has earned her place in the royal hierarchy, but is still not understood or fully valued.

“Are you admiring your lime avenue?” Louis XVI asks when he catches her starring out the window as their carriage flees through the estate’s back gardens. “I'm just saying good-bye,” she replies.

While history and art often pull in two different directions, it’s safe to say that like her cinematic counterpart, Antoinette was a woman—not unlike the director herself—who was born into privilege. However, she was never given the tools she needed to move beyond her gilded cage. And that is both the true tragedy, and Coppola’s artistic triumph.


Sais pas... L'ai toujours trouvée désespérément conventionnelle, la MA pondue par l'enfant gâtée d'Hollywood...

rien que la mort peut me faire cesser de vous aimer
Revenir en haut Aller en bas
Voir le profil de l'utilisateur


Nombre de messages : 1441
Localisation : La monarchie des Habsbourg
Date d'inscription : 01/03/2018

MessageSujet: Re: Sofia Coppola's Marie Antoinette is a Tragic Feminist Hero   Dim 4 Nov - 18:34

pimprenelle a écrit:
Sofia Coppola's Marie Antoinette is a Tragic Feminist Hero

Vous êtes d'accord avec ça ? Wink

Cher Pim.
C'est une évaluation très intéressante. Je suppose que oui, je suis d'accord avec lui.
Revenir en haut Aller en bas
Voir le profil de l'utilisateur
madame antoine


Nombre de messages : 6030
Date d'inscription : 30/03/2014

MessageSujet: Re: Sofia Coppola's Marie Antoinette is a Tragic Feminist Hero   Lun 5 Nov - 8:18

Je pense que le terme couramment utilisé pour qualifier la Reine Marie-Antoinette dans ce domaine est "proto-féministe", ce qui paraît effectivement judicieux tenant compte des risques d'anachronisme. En revanche, il ne me serait jamais venu à l'esprit de considérer le personnage mis en scène dans le film de Sofia Coppola comme un personnage féministe.

madame antoine

Plus rien ne peut plus me faire de mal à présent (Marie-Antoinette)
Revenir en haut Aller en bas
Voir le profil de l'utilisateur
Contenu sponsorisé

MessageSujet: Re: Sofia Coppola's Marie Antoinette is a Tragic Feminist Hero   

Revenir en haut Aller en bas
Sofia Coppola's Marie Antoinette is a Tragic Feminist Hero
Revenir en haut 
Page 1 sur 1
 Sujets similaires
» "Marie-Antoinette", le film de Sofia Coppola
» Exposition Marie Antoinette en 2008 au Grand Palais
» La Reine Marie -Antoinette.
» Marie-Antoinette et ses enfants (1787)

Permission de ce forum:Vous ne pouvez pas répondre aux sujets dans ce forum
Le Boudoir de Marie-Antoinette :: Autour de Marie-Antoinette :: A l'écran et sur les planches :: Marie Antoinette sur les écrans-
Sauter vers: